grim june anniversaries of a woman with a past (a growing past)
June, June, a month of days I want to forget:
1942
June 1 — my mother marries my father, from whom she has been divorced for 59 years. Since my birth, he has denied my existence and ignored me almost entirely.
1970
June 20th — anniversary of my first marriage
1981
June 14th — I meet my second husband.
1986
June 20-somethingth. My aunt has a family birthday for her father, my paternal grandfather. That occasion was the last time I saw my father — when, as I approached him to embrace him, forgiving all, he turned his back to me.
He’s still alive at 91.
2007
June 26th — I meet Performer.
2008
June 13th — six months since the last night spent with Performer, the night he referred to with warmth in a sexually charged email message sent to me as he and his ex-wife were on their way to tell their therapist they were getting back together.
2008
June 16th — six months to the day that Performer told me he was going back to his ex-wife (or, to be more accurate, had gone back to her).
2008
June 16/17 — long talk with Plan C about all the changes I’ve noted in him recently, i.e. in his relationship to me.
Not good.
It left me wondering not ‘if’ but ‘when’….
It’s not another woman, except that in part it’s W, his late wife. During the conversation (over the phone, late at night), he vacillated wildly between anger and apology, inarticulate silences and attempts to say what he felt. In brief: he misses his ‘life’ in the little town where he lives. As he said, ‘I don’t know that I want to spend 40 weekends a year in New York.’ In summer, especially, he misses golfing on Saturday as well as Sunday (he has been leaving at 1:20 on Sundays to golf in the afternoon). He says he is ‘in turmoil,’ meaning about his life and about my place in it. He loves his little town and wants to live there for the rest of his life and die there. I offered all sorts of adjustments, i.e. more summer weekends at his house, but it’s not clear that they would solve the problem. He also opined that he may be ‘too old’ (66) to ‘change his ways,’ i.e. not to lead his life the way he has been living it in his little town….’I'm finding that I’m not as flexible in adapting to this, and these problems are exacerbated by the distance and visiting.’
He was full of apologies for all the above, as he was talking. When I asked if there was no longer a lifetime commitment, he answered, ‘I can’t say the things you want.’
I reminded him of some of the things he had said in February and March, and he said, ‘Jesus Mimi I said those things and I did mean them.’
MIMI: Do you no longer think I’m your beshert? [a word I learned from him].
PLAN C: I’m trying to find out if you still are.
He has been discussing this ‘turmoil’ with his therapist. Whether it’s still continuing mourning (it’s not yet 3 years since W died; that was in August), the stress of coming to New York many (but not all) weekends, the absence of Saturday golf in his weekend and the disruption of his customary summer weekend customs, I don’t know. All of the above, probably.
I had asked him Saturday morning if he had discussed W with his therapist, and he said no, which surprised me. I’ve long believed that until he gets that relationship stabilized, and it is highly unstable, ours will be unstable also.
* * *
Many little things brought these new and uncertain feelings of Plan C’s to light, among them my question yesterday about what name to fill in on a form that asked for ‘person to be notified in case of accident or emergency.’ I asked him (over email) if that was he, and if something happened to me, ‘wouldn’t you want to know pretty quickly?’ I was thinking of the sentence in his profile where he said he was looking for ’someone to watch over and to watch over me.’
‘Oh, that was just because I liked the sound of the phrase,’ he said. He advised me to list my daughters, as he would list his sons, because ‘there are legal niceties involved in these things and it is meant to be and should be kin.’
But ‘it does not say “next of kin,”‘ I wrote him.
He wrote back, ‘I dont know. You asked what I thought so I told you what I would do.’
* * *
That exchange was important to me. If I had been asked the same question, I would have felt that I wanted to know first of anyone if something terrible had happened to Plan C, and nothing would stop me from rushing to the ER. I want a man who feels the same way about me, a man who wants his name in that line on the form.
* * *
Had an emergency meeting today with my wonderful psychiatrist, RS (‘Rolly’s shrink’), who was more helpful than I can say. I took notes on everything he said for an hour (yes, he gave me an hour).
Among other things, he said, ‘If his head is on straight, he’s going to be contented with someone like you. I don’t believe he’s going to find someone with all your qualities. A person like you is hard to come by.’ He said I was ‘highly eligible as a life companion.’ More along those lines: ‘you’re more than a match for him.’
Of the issue of distance and commuting, RS said, ‘I don’t believe that’s the crux of the matter: if two people are in love, amor vincit omnia. His exacerbation may be a rationalization.’ He also said, ‘It’s not between you and him. It’s between him and himself.’
We also discussed the somewhat hysterical alternation of guilt and idealizing in Plan C’s attitude to his late wife.
RS was also impatient with and critical of Plan C’s need for Saturday golf in the summer and his requirement of complete silence while he reads the newspaper every morning. Actually neither of those idiosyncrasies (if that’s the word…) bothers me, or at least, to me they aren’t deal-breakers. I can understand his need for golf, which definitely calms him; and Plan C (if this hasn’t become clear yet) needs calming. And I’ve been working on maintaining the newspaper silence, which I did note that he is allowed to break. I called him on that Sunday morning.
* * *
But RS also said he didn’t ‘want to see your heart broken prematurely by a man who may not break your heart in the end.’ He tried to remember a Latin proverb which I remembered and said: Festina lente — make haste slowly, my favorite proverb. He thought the relationship was ‘tenuous’ but by no means over.
Nevertheless, RS’s response to all I said about Plan C — and this was the first session we devoted entirely to him, because Plan C has not been much of a problem till recently — gives me pause. I have that sad sinking feeling you have when you discover someone you thought loves you absolutely doesn’t, but also a tough, businesslike confidence that I can find someone else. In short, I’m not entirely sure what to think, but I’m feeling strong anyway and carrying on with chores (but where on earth can I get a TravelMoney card in Manhattan?? anyone know?).
At any rate, our European trip (business for me, golf and touring for him) is still on, beginning next week. Of this, RS said, ‘If it goes poorly in [European country], then it’s over. But if it goes well, then you can’t tell. It’s not determined.’
* * *
Plan C’s email this morning:
Mimi, Darling girl, and you are, you are, good morning.
I am tested and sorry to be such a test to you.
My love to you,
Plan C
(‘Tested’ refers to his cholesterol test.) Not sure how to read ‘My love to you’ — before last night’s conversation, I would have read it as signifying the same love he declared in February. Now I don’t know.
Better not to answer that email, or the three others he sent later in the day. Plan C needs (to use a word he used this weekend and last night) SPACE.
* * *
He told me last night that when he first met me I seemed ‘whacky, zany, and independent,’ but now I seemed ‘needy.’ I came right back with a denial of that word: I’m not needy, I said. I need an appropriate amount of love, and you’re withdrawing yours and I’m calling you on that. That’s not needy.
* * *
Just when you thought this blog was getting boring — another twist in the plot!
I must be living my life to entertain … or to edify you.
* * *
June 18, 2008 at 3:19 am
Your response to Plan C’s “needy” dig was perfect. I need to remember that, should anyone ever sling the “needy” word at me.
My fingers are crossed …. I think that in many ways this is a normal part of a relationship. I don’t think it is necessarily the death knell … (and I certainly hope not!). Hang in there. That sinking feeling is the worst.
June 18, 2008 at 4:17 am
Oh Mimi — truly keeping my fingers crossed for you. I don’t know what to say. As your shrink said — sounds like this trip could be a good barometer for the relationship?
Really hoping for the best for you — whether that’s with him or without.
June 18, 2008 at 4:43 am
Oy. Entertaining this isn’t. Though I do feel the drama and anguish you must be feeling. I think your clarity later in the post is right on. As is RS – this is Plan C’s issue with himself, not you. And it’s not something that should be denied him. He must still be grieving for his wife and his old life that has to pretty much end – or at least drastically change- if life with you will continue. As much as you ask or try, you can’t help in that decision. Except perhaps having him miss you when you give him space. Good for you for visiting the shrink and handling this on your own terms while he figures it out. Here’s hoping whatever happens, it works best for you and what you deserve.
DT
June 18, 2008 at 5:17 am
thanks, guys. my feeling is actually that this is the beginning of what may be a long, slow ending…after all, i have to go to that wedding with him in mid-july, don’t i, to wear that dress?! but i doubt if he could undergo all the necessary changing this summer, the changing necessary to make things work. but we’ll see….
June 18, 2008 at 6:56 am
Golf is boring. You are not boring.
A trip to Europe is an interesting test, because you are not in your normal routine, and not on your home turf. I think it’s tough to interpret.
But if he wants space and says you are needy, there’s one thing to do, which is to retreat drastically. Wait for him to come to you.
Aw, who knows. I’m also highly eligible as a life companion, but that doesn’t mean I am one. I put my siblings down on the emergency contact form.
June 18, 2008 at 11:10 am
Er… actually, no. Not necessarily. I challenge that feeling of yours. I think it’s more about the evolving nature of your relationship that is de facto changing. It doesn’t mean it’s the end or even the beginning of the end. However, to wildy mis-quote Winston CVhurchill, it may be the end of the beginning.
I mean, look. He clearly needs some space, but i don’t think you need to be all doom and gloom quite yet. Honestly — I’m not saying this to placate you. I mean, i doubt you have one reader who doesn’t recognise this situation in some way. It does not necessarily mean the end of anything.
That email was a very very positive sign. Really. And the space thing only lends credence to that oft-repeated-to-the-point-of-being-gaggingly-boring gambit: “if you love some[thing? one?], set them free. If they come back, they are yours. If they don’t, they never were.”
I think that things could well end up being OK. Plan C strikes me as a very impetuous and passionate man, who wallows in pools of self-reflecton every once in a while… which he seems to be doing now. Bear in mind, relationships require compromise and change from both sides, which only gets more difficult as we get older and more set in our ways. I’m not sure i agree with RS about the unacceptability of the newpaper-reading silence and so on, rather i understand that it’s something that is important to Plan C, as is his golf. There are things that are important to you too, which should have an equal focus and visibility in the relationship.
And i totally agree with a&v above — that was a BRILLIANT repsonse to the needy thing, and i’m totally stealing it for future use.
And if it needs saying — no, i do not believe that you were overly needy — rather that, as DT says above, he needs his space. It’s about him. Not you, not really.
Basically, dear Mimi — don’t give up hope yet. Breathe deeply, and allow him his space, and while you do that, take your own space too. Your space is no less impotrtant than his, after all.
And i am not just saying this, but it is my true belief that all is not yet lost. June may be historically an awful month for you, but believing in the actuality of the negativity of the month is a self-fulfilling prophecy, and nothing more. (I don’t mean to seem harsh, believe me, I know the feeling.)
And now, rambling rant over, I will subside… Chin up, Mimi… xxx
June 18, 2008 at 11:51 am
pt, well, i certain am retreating drastically: no communication from me all yesterday!
we’ll see…..
minxie, that’s a very optimistic read…..i don’t know. have been thinking i would fake a cheerful upbeat manner in this foreign country, where i have lots of friends and ergo could easily fake, but doubt if i could do it for very long. i don’t know. but i appreciate your take on this and will probably reread it for comfort or the pleasure of yr style!
MEANWHILE, the wordpress Automatically Generated ‘possibly related posts’ [from everything on wordpress] include the following:
1) A Happy Anniversary
2) Apathy slur on cops
!!!!!!
go figure.
-mimi
June 18, 2008 at 1:10 pm
Oh my, I feel like I have walked into the middle of good movie but do not know what is happening. The beginning of this entry was so upsetting, about your father turning away from you, how horrible. And as for Plan C, the very little that I know it sounds like he loves you but not the lifestyle. He is just not willing to give up his life for his bsherat (a word we use all the time, and it is not used lightly). good luck, I hope I have time to read some archives for the back story.
June 18, 2008 at 1:17 pm
“a good movie” — thank you!!! well, fingers crossed, a good movie someday. first it has to be a good novel, and before that a good blog, and before that, i’d like to have some sense of the ending, happy or not — but i have a feeling most agents would prefer a happy ending. myself, i prefer a muted, ambiguous-though-not-unhopeful ending. you should start reading at the beginning, february 2007, for the story so for. i’m still living that story….
June 20, 2008 at 3:35 am
Keeping my fingers crossed for you as well. As for emergency contacts, I usually see that in a pretty practical manner – I actually generally still list my ex-boyfriend (still a dear friend) because he is local and my family is not, so if I end up in the hospital, I want him there in a few minutes rather than them in hours. Well, he can call them and they’ll still be there, but I want him there in the meantime.
Of course, I realize that not everyone has such a completely trusting and loving relationship with exes…